Cautionary Tales - Family Compounds - The Good, The Bad - Episode 198

Hey there, Legal Tea Listeners –This is your host, Jenny Rozelle! Today’s episode of Legal Tea is the “cautionary tales” topic. And on these “cautionary tales” episodes of Legal Tea, we normally talk about real-life cases with real-life clients that are things me or my office have worked on -or they are things that I think are generally good things to be aware of, so you don’t turn into a cautionary tale on my Legal Tea podcast one day! Today is about a concept (with a couple real life examples) that I am seeing more-and-more …. that I call a family compound or another term that gets used sometimes (but not as often as family compound) is muti-generational living arrangement. As soon as I describe it, you very well may know someone that has done this – or maybe it’s even you! I want to talk about one situation that has worked well (at least so far) and another situation that it’s not worked so well – so let’s first start by describing what I am talking about…

It's essentially a piece of land owned by a family (say Mom and Dad) where multiple dwellings are built, allowing different branches or generations of the family to live in close proximity to one another. Think of it like this: imagine a large plot of land. Initially, Mom and Dad build their main house there (or maybe when Mom and Dad purchased the land, there was one house on it). As their children grow and start their own families, instead of moving far away, perhaps one or two of the children build houses on the same property. This creates like a cluster of homes, all belonging to the same family. Does that make sense? So, that’s what I am talking about. It’s something I have seen before, but it seems to be “crossing my desk” a bit more nowadays. So, I wanted to talk about it – 1) generally speaking and 2) share a couple stories about a “family compound” working well and another where some drama went down.

Let’s start with a good story – and I should say, good-so-far story. This family compound story is kind of playing out right now. So here are the details: Take John and Jane …John and Jane had two children – a daughter and a son. Daughter is married with children. Son is not married and has no children. Okay, so John and Jane purchased a rural property (about 20 acres) with an existing home already on it. The plan (and what ended up happening) was that their daughter and her family, including her husband and children, relocated to this existing house, while the parents began construction on their own residence on the same property. Fast forward time, John and Jane successfully built their house – and honestly, what was particularly impressive about their approach is the intentionality behind it. The “big picture” idea of this plan was that … By building their own home on the shared land, they effectively created an aging-in-place solution with family support nearby—maintaining their independence while establishing a safety net for their later years. Smart!

Now, in the “big picture” plan, they have long thought (and wanted) their son to one day move to the property too. In fact, in their planning, they have a designated portion of the property for their son, should he want to choose to join this family compound. However, knowing their son's preferences quite well, there is a distinct reality to consider—he is thoroughly enjoying living in the city, with minimal indication he would want to trade his city living for rural family living. John and Jane addressed this reality in their estate plan – Rather than making assumptions about everyone's desires, they collaborated with us to structure an estate plan accommodating both scenarios. Their plan works effectively whether their son eventually decides to build on the property or maintains his urban lifestyle indefinitely.

So, one of the big takeaways from this situation is that I want to emphasize how crucial proper legal structuring is when establishing any form of shared family compound like this. Every aspect must be considered and properly documented—ownership divisions, decision-making protocols, potential exit strategies—all require clear communication. I have witnessed well-intentioned family compounds deteriorate into contentious situations when these elements aren't thoroughly addressed upfront. In fact, we will take about a situation here in a second that did not go well.

With John and Jane’s family, though, they exemplify smart estate planning that is combined with practical foresight. I was so glad to see that their planning extended beyond immediate considerations (i.e. “we’re going to do this and figure it out later!”) to long-term implications (involving more questions … than assumptions). That is because they had questions regarding inheritance, property transfer mechanisms, potential tax consequences, and financial obligations between siblings following their passing.

Okay, let’s shift to a story of a family compound situation that has not gone so well, shall we? Alrighty, so this story goes a little something like this…Meet David and Brenda. What started as David and Brenda's vision for a close-knit family compound has unfortunately evolved into a complicated situation that keeps everyone up at night. After purchasing their rural property years ago, they built their own home and eventually helped both their adult children establish houses on the same land. Their dream was simple: multiple generations living near each other, sharing holidays, helping with grandkids, and creating lasting family memories. You know … sounds like a movie, huh! Well, like some movies, things have taken QUITE the turn…

The turning point came after David and Brenda formally deeded portions of the property to each of their children. It was well-intentioned, but this decision has revealed unforeseen complications. One child's spouse has become increasingly difficult, causing tension that ripples through family gatherings and even day-to-day interactions. What was once easy conversation over shared property lines has become awkward encounters and avoided eye contact. So now, the family faces a troubling question that nobody wants to discuss openly but everyone worries about privately: what happens if this strained marriage ends in divorce?

The implications are serious and far-reaching. The deeded land—meant to stay within the family for generations—could potentially become subject to divorce proceedings, possibly resulting in maybe being forced to buy back the land at market value to get it “back.” Is that not wild to think about? So, needless to say, David and Brenda find themselves in a position they never anticipated, realizing too late that their estate planning should have included protective measures for such scenarios. The situation underscores the vital importance of thorough legal planning for family compounds—not just addressing the optimistic outcomes, but preparing for challenging possibilities as well. Protective clauses, rights of first refusal, and carefully structured property agreements are not just legalese and formal things; they're essential safeguards for preserving both family harmony and the integrity of shared family property for years to come. And yes, this family never thought in a million years this would happen to them.

So, we have heard one good-so-far story and one not-great story about family compounds. Let’s talk about some takeaways and things to know and consider on this whole topic… When establishing a family compound, proper legal structuring is absolutely essential from the beginning. Families could consider utilizing an LLC or family trust as the ownership vehicle rather than deeding property directly to family members (as David and Brenda did). These entities provide protection by keeping the property within the family while establishing clear rules for ownership and what happens at various forks in the road. For example, they can include provisions that give remaining family members the right of first refusal if someone wants or needs to sell their interest, preventing outside parties from acquiring shares through divorce or other circumstances.

Estate planning for family compounds requires specialized attention. Consider creating separate trusts for different portions of the property or establishing a comprehensive family trust with clear succession plans. Include provisions that accommodate family members who may never want to live on the compound (like John and Jane did), perhaps through equalization with other assets or buy-out mechanisms. Remember that successful family compounds balance legal protection with flexibility—and additionally,, your documents should provide security (to you and your family) while acknowledging that family needs evolve over generations.

A last thing I want to mention is … to think very carefully about how the “family compound” property transitions upon death or incapacity. Will surviving spouses retain lifetime rights to remain in their homes? (Like in David and Brenda’s situation, what if the one child and her spouse stay married, yet the child passes away – leaving the spouse that has been difficult with the house?) And how will decision-making authority transfer? Without proper planning, a family compound can become super fractured through multiple inheritance cycles, potentially forcing property sales to satisfy heirs or tax obligations. The most successful multi-generational family compounds typically have detailed succession plans that maintain the property's integrity while respecting individual family members' changing needs and circumstances.

This was kind of a unique topic – but I am definitely seeing more and more clients (as well as people in my personal life) so I hope this episode was interesting and maybe even applicable to some of you. If you know of someone that is doing or plans to do a “family compound” kind of thing – maybe send them this episode. It may end up saving them headache and money (if their situation has to ever be cleaned up!).

Alrighty, let’s shift to a sneak peak of next week, which we’re circling back to the “current trends” topic where we talk about things that are going on currently that impact my estate and elder law world – or maybe, things that I have stumbled upon on the news or social media that is relevant to this podcast. I am trying to get this episode recorded kind of quickly, so I have not spent even three seconds thinking of a specific topic for next week – sorry! You will just have to tune in next week to find out, Legal Tea Listeners, so until then, be well and talk soon!

Sources:

None.