Cautionary Tales - The Power (and Peril) of a Power of Attorney - Episode 243

Hey there, Legal Tea Listeners –This is your host, Jenny Rozelle! Today’s episode of Legal Tea is the “cautionary tales” topic. And on these “cautionary tales” episodes of Legal Tea, we normally talk about real-life cases with real-life clients that are things me or my office have worked on -or they are things that I think are generally good things to be aware of, that way you don’t turn into a cautionary tale on my Legal Tea podcast one day! So… we’re back to our normal rotation of topics between cautionary tales, celebrity estate planning, and current trends following a three episode mini series on the Vanderbilt family. That was a doozy, wasn’t it? So today, we are doing a “cautionary tale” episode and the topic is going to be all about the POWER, or lack thereof, of a Power of Attorney. This document, a Power of Attorney, is something that is super, super vital to have, but it is super, super easy to mess up for several reasons – whether it’s just a crappy document, whether it’s picking not a great person for the role, or whether it’s a lack of understanding of what the document actually does and grants to someone else. That’s what today is on, my friends, so you don’t fall into any of these “traps” in Power of Attorney land. Let’s dive in!

We've got three big buckets to cover today, and I hope, by the end of this episode, you are going to walk away knowing exactly what to watch out for. And honestly? This is one of those episodes where I really hope you share it with someone - a parent, a sibling, a friend - because this stuff affects everyone eventually. Let's start with bucket number one -  which is about a the Power of Attorney just being … kind of crappy. What do I even mean by that? Here's the thing - a Power of Attorney is a legal document, and like any legal document, the literal way it's written matters enormously. And I know what some of you are thinking: "I just downloaded one off the internet, it's like two pages, it looked fine." And look, I'm not here to make you feel bad about that, but I am here to tell you that "looked fine" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in that sentence. And what I can also say … is that a poorly written POA can fail you in a few really specific ways.

First - it can be too vague. Like, it just says your agent can handle your "financial affairs." Okay, cool. But can they access your brokerage account? Can they sell your house? Can they open a new account in your name to pay your bills? A vague document leaves all of that up in the air, and here's what happens in the real world - the bank, or the title company, or whoever your agent is trying to work with? They may say no. They're going to say "this document doesn't specifically authorize that," and your agent is going to be stuck. The whole point of the document is to let someone act on your behalf, and if it's too vague, it just... may not work.

Second - it can become a bit too old. This is a big one that people do not really think about. You had a POA drafted in 2005? A lot has changed. State laws change. Financial institutions update their requirements. And wild enough, I have heard about some banks that flat-out refuse to honor a POA that is more than “X” years old. Do they really have a leg to stand on to require that? Not really. POAs typically do not have an expiration date, but sometimes banks like to make their own rules and cause us headaches. So again, this creates a massive problem right at the moment when you need the document to work the most - usually when you're incapacitated or in a crisis.

Third -then there's the issue of state-specific requirements. Every state has its own rules about how a POA has to be signed, witnessed, notarized. Miss a step? The document might not be valid at all. This is why the "I found a template online" approach is genuinely risky. That template, and hear me loud and clear – even if they say they are state-specific, might not be built for your state. I have seen that happen a zillion times. I actually just saw documents this week, that were drafted via an online platform, that had community property language in Indiana documents – and guess what? Indiana is NOT a community property state.

Alrighty, let’s get to bucket two. Picking the wrong person for the role. So, your agent under a Power of Attorney - sometimes called your attorney-in-fact - this person has enormous power. Like, depending on what your document says, they might be able to access your bank accounts, sell your property, make investment decisions, etc. This is not a small thing. A Power of Attorney can be, depending on the type, can be a VERY powerful document. And yet, people pick their agents for all the wrong reasons all the time. They pick the oldest kid because "that's just what you do." They pick the one who lives closest. They pick someone they love without stopping to ask whether that person is actually equipped for the role.

And here's a little bit of an uncomfortable truth: financial abuse by a POA agent is one of the most common forms of elder abuse in this country. And a lot of the time? It is a family member. It is not some stranger. It is a son or a daughter or a sibling who sees the access, sees the money, and just... yeah. Either takes it or abuses the power they have. Now, I, of course, am not saying your family is full of bad people. What I am saying is that power changes things, and money changes things, and the combination of both? It can bring out sides of people that nobody expected. So what that in mind, what should you actually be looking for in an agent?

You want someone who is responsible - like, genuinely, provably responsible. Not just a good person. Someone who pays their own bills on time, makes sound decisions, doesn't have a history of financial instability. You want someone who is organized. Being a POA agent means keeping records, communicating with institutions, possibly filing taxes on your behalf. It is paperwork-heavy. If your candidate cannot manage their own paperwork, that should be a red flag. You want someone who can handle conflict - because sometimes being an agent means saying no to other family members, making unpopular decisions, holding the line. That requires a certain kind of emotional backbone. And you may even want someone who does not have a huge personal financial stake in your decisions. Because that is sometimes where conflicts of interest creep in. And honestly, for some people, the right answer is not a family member at all. There are professionals - people whose whole job is to act as an agent for clients. It is worth knowing that is an option.

Lastly on to bucket three. And this one is so, so common. People create a Power of Attorney without really truly understanding what they have just created. And I get it - the legal terminology is dense, the documents are not exactly a page-turner, and sometimes the attorney you're working with just kind of... hands it to you and says "sign here." But the lack of understanding can be really costly. Real quick - I just want to name-drop the different types so you know they exist, because this alone trips people up. You’ve got a General Power of Attorney, a Limited Power of Attorney, a Durable Power of Attorney, and a Springing Power of Attorney. Those are the main flavors. And I'll just throw in - some states use the term "Healthcare Power of Attorney" for the document that covers medical decision-making, but that is a whole separate conversation and not really what I am talking about today. Today is all about the financial and legal lane. The point is: these are not all the same thing, they do not all work the same way, and if you do not know which one you have, that is absolutely worth finding out.

But here's what I really want to dig into - because even people who have the right type of document often have no idea what is actually inside it. And that is where things can get dangerous. Let's talk about scope. Because a Power of Attorney doesn't just say "hey, handle my stuff." Depending on how it's written, it can grant some really sweeping authority. Some POAs include the power to make gifts - meaning your agent can literally give away your money. To other family members. To themselves, even, if the document allows it and there's no guardrail in place. That's not hypothetical. That happens. Some documents give your agent the authority to change your beneficiary designations - so the people who were set to inherit your retirement account or your life insurance? Your agent could potentially change that. Some allow your agent to create trusts on your behalf. Some give them control over your business interests.  They can do A LOT.  And here's the thing - most people who sign these documents have no idea those powers are in there. They just know they picked someone they trust and signed the thing. But "I trust this person" and "I understand what I've given this person" are two very different statements. You need both.

And one more thing before we move on -  you need to also understand the timing of all this. When does your agent's authority actually kick in? Is it the moment you sign the document? Does it only activate if you become incapacitated? And on the other end - when does it end? Is it when you pass away? Because some POAs are actually designed to be temporary. Like, really limited windows of time - maybe you're traveling, maybe you are in surgery, maybe you just need someone to close on a house while you are out of the country. That is a very different animal than a long-term durable POA. So make sure you’ve got a clear understanding of when that authority turns on, what can turn it off, and when it naturally runs out. Those are not small details.

Okay, so let's bring this all home. Power of Attorney - incredibly powerful document, right? Genuinely one of the most important documents you can have in place as part of your overall estate plan. But it can go sideways fast, and I’ve seen it go sideways fast, if there is a poorly written document that does not hold up when it needs to, if you have picked someone who is not the right fit for the role or who could take advantage of the access they have been given, or if you just signed something without really understanding what authority you handed over. None of this is meant to scare you out of having a POA - quite the opposite. I want you to have one, but I want it to be a good one. I want you to be thoughtful about who you pick, and I want you to actually understand what you have signed. That way, you, my friend, do not turn into a cautionary tale on this podcast one day!

Alrighty, let’s shift to a sneak peak of next week, which we’re circling back to the “current trends” topic where we talk about things that are going on currently that impact my estate and elder law world – or maybe, things that I have stumbled upon on the news or social media that is relevant to this podcast. Next week is going to be about where things like Pre-Marital Agreements (Pre-Nups) intersect with estate planning. PS – It’s usually when people choose to get remarried or married much later-in-life and their concern is NOT divorce, but keeping assets going to their family. So yeah. That’s next time. I’ll talk to you then, Legal Tea Listeners, be well and take care!

Sources:

None.