top of page
Search

Celebrity Estate Planning - Estate of Robert (Bobby) Knight - Episode 275

Writer: Jenny Rozelle, Host of Legal Tea
Jenny Rozelle, Host of Legal Tea
4 days ago
7 min read

Hey there, Legal Tea Listeners! This is your host, Jenny Rozelle. We are here for episode 275 –and we are circling back to an “estate planning of the rich and famous” episode where we chat about celebrities or high profile folks and their estate planning (or lack thereof!). So today, my friends, today… we are talking about legendary coach, Robert Knight … or who was better known as Bob or Bobby Knight … and specifically, what happened with his estate after he died in late 2023. But, as we always do, I want to start with a little bit about Bobby … By the way, I’m going to call him Bobby for the rest of the episode … not Robert or Bob because that’s how I remember him being known as “Bobby” … anyway, I want to start with a little bit about Bobby more personally speaking first, then shift to estate stuff after that.

If you know anything about Indiana basketball, you know the name Bobby Knight. Bobby was born in Ohio in 1940, played basketball at Ohio State, and after a short stint coaching high school basketball, joined the Army. He eventually became the head basketball coach at Army at just 24 years old. He was young, but he already had the personality and coaching philosophy that would define his career: demanding, disciplined, incredibly competitive, and not particularly concerned with telling people what they wanted to hear.

Personally speaking, Bobby was married twice. He married Nancy Falk in 1963, and they had two sons, Tim and Pat, before divorcing in 1985. In 1988, he married Karen Vieth, who had been a high school basketball coach herself, so she understood the basketball world pretty well. Karen remained his wife until his death, and both of Knight's sons went on to have careers in basketball, with Pat eventually becoming a college coach himself.

And then, of course, there was Indiana, which by the way, this podcast is based out of Indiana, so this episode is fun for me to do. Bobby took over as the Indiana University Hoosiers head coach in 1971, when he was just 30, and spent the next 29 years turning Indiana basketball into one of the most prominent programs in the country. He won three national championships, and the 1976 team went 32–0 and remains the last undefeated men's Division I national championship team. He also coached the 1984 U.S. Olympic team to a gold medal. But Bobby’s legacy was about much more than the wins. He was a teacher, and he demanded that his players understand the game, not just memorize plays. At the same time, his temper became almost as famous as his coaching. His confrontations with players, officials, fans and the media were legendary, and eventually that became a major part of his story. In 2000, Indiana fired Bobby.

Bobby went on to coach at Texas Tech, where he continued to win, and he retired in 2008 with 902 career victories. But for years, his relationship with Indiana remained pretty fractured. Then, surprisingly, that started to change. In 2019, Knight began making public appearances in Bloomington again, and in February 2020, he returned to Assembly Hall for an Indiana-Purdue game, nearly 20 years after his firing. Former players were there, the crowd went crazy, and it was an incredibly emotional homecoming. Whatever had happened between Bobby and the university, it was pretty clear that his connection to Indiana basketball had never really disappeared.

By then, though, his health had begun to decline. People who saw him publicly in his later years noticed significant memory problems, although his family did not publicly disclose a specific diagnosis. He was hospitalized with an undisclosed illness in April 2023 and returned home afterward, with his family asking for privacy. On November 1, 2023, Bobby died at his home in Bloomington at the age of 83, surrounded by his family. He was survived by his wife, Karen, and his two sons, Tim and Pat. And I think there's something interesting about the way his story ended. Bobby Knight spent decades being one of the loudest, most recognizable and sometimes most controversial people in college basketball. But his final years were much quieter. Ultimately, he was back in Bloomington, near the basketball program that had defined so much of his life, and surrounded by his family.

So, what happened to Bobby's estate after he died? Well, here's where this story gets a little frustrating because despite how famous Bobby Knight was, I could not find much publicly available information about the actual estate plan itself. I did not find a published copy of his will, a trust agreement, or reliable reporting that tells us exactly who was named as executor or how his assets were ultimately divided. And that is actually a pretty interesting thing in and of itself. Because when we talk about the estates of famous people, we tend to expect there to be this giant public trail - the will, the trust, the probate case, somebody fighting over something. But that's not necessarily how it works. A lot of estate planning happens privately, and unless there's a probate proceeding, a dispute, or some other reason the documents become public, we may never know exactly what the plan said. And sometimes, frankly, the absence of a public estate fight is itself a sign that there was not a reason for the family to take things into court. But we don't actually know what happened behind the scenes, so I don't want to overstate that.

What we do know is that Bobby had already been thinking about how to turn some of his basketball legacy into something useful for his family. In 2012, while he was still alive, he auctioned off a number of significant pieces of memorabilia, including his three Indiana championship rings and items from the 1984 Olympic team. And the reason wasn't simply that he didn't want the stuff anymore. He was doing it to help fund his grandchildren's education. So there's this really tangible example of somebody taking something with enormous sentimental value and turning it into an asset that could benefit the next generation. And I think that's a pretty interesting estate planning conversation in and of itself, because sometimes the things we leave behind aren't necessarily things our family wants to keep. Sometimes the better gift is turning that asset into something useful. That’s actually another estate planning lesson: if you have personal property, it is worth thinking about what you actually want to happen to it. Do you want your kids to inherit it? Do you want it sold? Do you want the proceeds to go to someone else? Do you want certain things to stay in the family and other things converted to cash? Those are decisions that can be made intentionally instead of leaving your family to figure them out after you're gone.

Then there's what happened with Bobby's name and likeness. After his death, there was a family effort to preserve and commercially manage that legacy through Knight Legacy, LLC. And I want to be precise here because I initially saw this described as though Bobby's estate plan had created an LLC specifically for his posthumous NIL rights, but I don't think the public record supports that. The family's own website identifies Pat Knight, Bobby’s son, as the founder of Knight Legacy, LLC and says the company's purpose is to honor, promote and preserve his father's legacy. It also says Knight Legacy is the only licensed company using Robert Montgomery Knight's name and likeness. So, essentially, the family has created a business structure around the value of Bobby Knight's name, image and legacy. And I think that's really interesting from an estate planning perspective, because when we talk about an estate, we're not just talking about the house and the checking account. A person's name and likeness can have value. So can memorabilia, photographs, writings, intellectual property and other things that are uniquely connected to that person.

And then there's the part of this story that I think is especially relevant to what we're talking about here on this podcast: Bobby's cognitive decline. In the years before his death, there were very public indications that his memory was declining, particularly when he appeared in public. But his family never publicly disclosed a specific diagnosis, and I haven't found evidence that there was a guardianship, a will contest or some other publicly documented legal fight over whether his cognitive impairment affected his estate plan. And here's where I think it's really important not to make a leap that we sometimes see people make: the fact that someone has cognitive impairment does not automatically mean they couldn't make or update an estate plan. Those are two different questions. The legal question is what the person's capacity was at the time the particular document was signed. Did they understand what they were doing? Did they understand, generally, what property they had and who the people were who might reasonably be expected to benefit from their estate? That's a very different question from, "Did this person have memory problems?"

And honestly, I think this is one of the most important things to take away from Bobby's story. We can look at somebody toward the end of their life and say, "Well, clearly, they were having memory problems." But that doesn't tell us what was happening five years earlier, two years earlier, or even on a particular day when an estate planning document was signed. Capacity is not necessarily an all-or-nothing, permanent status. And that's why, when we're dealing with a client who has cognitive concerns, the timing and circumstances surrounding the planning can matter so much.

So, ultimately, we don't have a public window into exactly what Bobby Knight's estate plan said. And honestly, that's probably the most responsible conclusion to draw from the available information. We know that he had taken steps during his lifetime to use valuable memorabilia to benefit his grandchildren. We know that his family has continued to manage the commercial value of his name and likeness through Knight Legacy. We know that he experienced cognitive decline toward the end of his life. But we don't have public evidence showing that anything resulted in a challenge to his estate plan. And I think that's an important thing to know and end on because sometimes the most interesting estate planning story is not what we know happened in court. It's what we do NOT know, because you know what… someone, like Bobby Knight, may have planned privately, and there simply wasn't a public fight that gave us a window into it. And, frankly, from an estate planning perspective, there is something to be said for that. We don't need to know the details of somebody's estate plan for it to have done exactly what it was supposed to do for that family.

Alrighty, let’s wrap this one up and shift to a sneak peak at next week. Next week we’re back to a “cautionary tale” episode where we talk about real-life clients, real-life cases that I, or my office, have worked on -or- maybe they are just generally good things to know/be aware of so you don’t slip up and turn into a cautionary tale one day. Talk to you next week! Take care and be well!

SOURCES:

 
 
 

Comments


©2021 Legal Tea Podcast

bottom of page